User Ratings & Opinions
|
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||
Excellent Holster
User: T P, Jun 7, 2007
This is an outstanding holster for a Treo 650, and I recommend it for anyone looking for an easy snap-on/off-type holder for their Treo. It holds the Treo securely, face-in, as well as covers the stylet and doesn't bother the SD card. The phone pops-out easily for answering, and the rotation assists in this maneuver. This is my second one, as a replacement for my first one which lasted 2 years of everyday use.
poor quality item
User: Alex Moreano, Feb 2, 2007
Pros: Treo fell out LESS often than with original equipment holster
Cons: numerous-see below
A good holster, but not perfect ...
Overall, Id say that Ive been satisfied with this holster. The phone fits in the holster very snug, and its easy to release the phone quickly from it. The holster has not caused me to lose a memory card, nor has the memory card ever come loose.
However, there is one problem this holster suffers from, and many other reviewers have already pointed this out. The swivel clip wears out after 6 to 9 months, causing the phone to hang too loosely on my belt. This is bad, because it allows the phone to snag onto obstacles: such as the arm of my desk chair, my coat (when taking off), or the seat belt of my car. This causes the phone to get pulled out of the holster, and on several occasions, I have seen my phone fall several feet to the ground. One day, the screen finally cracked.
So now, rather than suffer the potential of another cracked screen, I simply order another holster as soon as the swivel clip becomes loose. But at $30, this holster is a terrible value, when Im replacing it every 6 to 9 months. However, I havent found any reasonable alternative.
Perhaps for this next Seidel holster, I will consider using super-glue to permanently set the swivel in the upright position.
User: James V, Apr 24, 2008
Pros: phone fits well, screen is protected
Cons: swivel clip wears out after 6 to 9 months
Overall, Id say that Ive been satisfied with this holster. The phone fits in the holster very snug, and its easy to release the phone quickly from it. The holster has not caused me to lose a memory card, nor has the memory card ever come loose.
However, there is one problem this holster suffers from, and many other reviewers have already pointed this out. The swivel clip wears out after 6 to 9 months, causing the phone to hang too loosely on my belt. This is bad, because it allows the phone to snag onto obstacles: such as the arm of my desk chair, my coat (when taking off), or the seat belt of my car. This causes the phone to get pulled out of the holster, and on several occasions, I have seen my phone fall several feet to the ground. One day, the screen finally cracked.
So now, rather than suffer the potential of another cracked screen, I simply order another holster as soon as the swivel clip becomes loose. But at $30, this holster is a terrible value, when Im replacing it every 6 to 9 months. However, I havent found any reasonable alternative.
Perhaps for this next Seidel holster, I will consider using super-glue to permanently set the swivel in the upright position.
Expensive and inconvenient
User: Jake Rhedy, Mar 28, 2008
I had an old Seidio swivel clip holster, the predecessor to this one, for a few years and loved it. I just bought this one for my Treo 650 and am constantly annoyed because it bumps the sound switch on top and keeps turning on the ringer for my phone when I have it on silent. Add to that the fact that I just found out Seidio sells these for half the price of TreoCentral on their own website.
Too Secure
User: Thomas deHoop, Oct 25, 2007
I love a holster design. I had the Cellet holster, but after it fell out 5 times in the first week and scratched the case, I gave up. The clip holds a 1 mm lip in the design. Not to secure. The holster is VERY secure. So secure that it ruined the finish clipping in for only a week. It also doesnt easily clip in straight with one hand. If placed on cockeyed, the clip will eject the card.
| See all 14 User Opinions... |
